Below is a list of the staff

  • Rev. Chuck Cary 
    Rev. Chuck Cary 

    Interim Pastor
    631-283-1296 ext 102

    Rev. Chuck is the retired pastor of The Westhampton Presbyterian Church.  Prior to his retirement from Westhampton Presbyterian Church, he was the Pastor and Head of Staff of the Mooring Presbyterian Church in Naples, FL  (1,400+ members). He is very much involved in the community and has served as a Rotarian, elected school board member -  serving as both president and vice-president. He has been a board member for Habitat for Humanity and has served on the Advisory Board and been the Instructor of Pastoral Care for East End Hospice.  Rev. Chuck has also been part of the Anti-Bias Task Force sponsored by local government, and various ecumenical/interfaith groups dedicated to the common good.

    Rev. Chuck's office hours are Tuesday through Friday 9am to noon and afternoons by appointment.  His door is always open when he's in the office.  Afternoons are "by appointment" since they are Rev. Chuck's time to make visitations to our shut-ins and hospital/nursing home patients.  Stop by the office or call and say "hello"

    Rev. Chuck and his wife Millie enjoy spending time with their adult children and their grandchildren.



  • Shelley Bennett 

    Administrative Assistant
    631-283-1296 ext 101

    Shelley has been with us at First Presbyterian since October 4, 1998.  She enjoys working here and also singing in the Chancel Choir and ringing in the Handbell Choir. 

  • Terry Stubelek 

    Director of Christian Education

    Terry is our Director of Christian Education and has many years experience teaching children at the Elementary level in Southampton School District.

  • Kelly D'Angelo 

    Youth Director



  • Marge Squires 

    Financial Secretary

  • Katherine Mades 

    Choir Director

  • Kim Makowski 


  • Midge Fowler 

    Handbell Director